Paper 1 clarifications
There have been several clarifications given by the IB over the past few months. Many have said that they are difficult to follow. In order to assist, I am organizing these clarifications below, based on the relevant aspects of the curriculum. These clarifications are from the assessment clarification (June 27, 2018), the FAQ document (June 2018) and clarifications sent to all workshop leaders (Sept 19, 2018).
This page shows where we are with clarifications as of October 14, 2018. This page will continue to be updated as further clarifications are made available.
The following questions are often asked about Paper 1. We have received the clarifications below. For specifics about how questions are set, please see the " Assessment clarifications" page.
1. Are theories also considered" research?
This is a change in assessment practice. Research now means only "studies." Theory is considered part of Criterion B - knowledge and understanding which is assessed separately from "use of research."
2. May students use older research?
Teachers need to make the judgment call about the use of older studies. Studies such as Bartlett and Ebbinghaus may be seen as still valid. However, other older studies may be considered too old to be of value. No further guidance is given on this. My own experience is that universities tend to have limits on the age of studies. Many would not accept research from the 19th century accept for historical context. I would recommend sticking to research from 1960 to the present.
3. How many studies are required?
With regard to how much research is necessary in an SAQ or ERQ, the response is still a bit unclear. All responses require research. Therefore, all SAQs will require a study. The clarification reads:
As Psychology is evidence-based, it is expected that students will use their knowledge of research to support their argument. There is no prescription as to which or how many pieces of research are appropriate for their response. As such it is important that the research selected is relevant, appropriate and useful in supporting the argument they are making. One piece of research that is clearly relevant, appropriate and used well is better than several pieces that repeat the same point over and over.
4. May students use animal research on Paper 1?
The official response is as follows:
Questions that specifically ask for one study related to human behaviour should focus on a human study in the student response. Animal research may be used as supplementary support, but students must clearly and explicitly show how it is linked to human behaviour. If this link is not made relevant then the inclusion of the study cannot be awarded marks. Students who are unable to make this explicit link will not be able to achieve in the highest markband.
My takeaway from this is that for an essay, they could use animal research. For an SAQ, they should not.
The most important clarification regards the use of "and". There are several places in the guide where "and" is used. The IB has sent a clarification that "and" may be "and/or" and the terms will not be separated on paper 1. (This is different on Paper 2). Examples of content that uses "and" is as follows:
Please note that the IB may use only the word "and" for these questions. So, it would be possible to ask about the effect of local and global influences, or they may ask it as "and/or" which would give students a choice. They will never, however, ask a question on research methods in the study of pheromones. The question would have to be "Discuss research methods in the study of hormones and/or pheromones."
The drop-down menus
Another significant clarification regards the drop-down menus in the guide in the content column. These drop-down menus will not be assessed until May 2020. In the May 2019 and November 2019 exam sessions, only the content heading (in boldface) may be used to set a question. As of May 2020, the drop down menus may be used to set SAQs only, not essay questions. However, the drop-downs are not always clearly written. The IB has therefore clarified which terms may be used from the drop-down menus to set questions. Please see the "drop down" menus below.
Sample exam questions for paper 1, section A
Outline how neural networks are formed, with reference to one study. [9 marks]
Describe one research study related to schema theory. [9 marks]
As was stated in the Assessment clarification page, when asked about research methods, students should write about experiments, observations, interviews and case studies. The clarification reads: Twin, adoption, and longitudinal studies are examples of research designs. Meta-analyses are a quantitative statistical analysis of several similar experiments or studies for which the pooled data is tested for statistical significance. To clarify further, twin, adoption, longitudinal studies and meta-analyses are not considered research methods and will not be accepted on IB exams as valid responses. This also applies to Paper 2.
When studying the brain, fMRI, MRI, EEG, CAT, PET are the most frequent techniques used to study the brain; however, they are not research methods.
How many examples to teach?
The following clarification was made by the IB:
If, under a content heading, students are instructed to study one or more of an optional list, questions will be general in nature (i.e., not formulated using the named options). For example, the list of cultural dimensions associated with the topic-cultural origins of behaviour and cognition, within the sociocultural approach.
This means that they may not ask a specific cultural dimension or cognitive bias on the exam. Where the guide says "one or more," one is enough.
How will the extension questions be asked?
The extension questions may be asked in combination with the topics. This means that they may students to Discuss the ethical considerations in animal research on the brain and behaviour. They may also be asked as a stand alone question which would allow students to use any content in the unit to address the question.
There was also the following language change in the guide:
Assessment questions on the cognitive approach for HL extension will use the term “technologies” when referring to digital and modern technologies.